There is one over the top scene where he his trying to play a fast beat on the drum kit for hours until his hands are dripping with blood despite applying multiple band-aids. However Andrew has an obsession with practice to the point of pain. As a music student Andrew is pushed by the professor and himself to be one of “the greats” of jazz like saxophonist Charlie Parker or drummer Buddy Rich. While Whiplash offers specialized services for clients in the music industry, its typical clients are e-commerce companies with a strong online presence. In “Whiplash,” the promising feature debut of writer-director Damien Chazelle, J.K. Simmons plays a music professor named Fletcher, a tightly coiled martinet who joins a … Maybe they found a balance that allowed for intense practice but still be normal stable people. Chazelle directs the film with such a … I'll pass on the story—due to its clear, unrealistic and melodramatic aftertaste. Whiplash was a great movie that got jazz wrong - admittedly in subtle ways. Consider the great music from bands like the Beatles or singer/songwriters such as Neil Young who while not being the most accomplished players have created some amazing beautiful music. Would this lead to Andrew becoming another aggressive musician yelling at and intimidating his band members like Terence Fletcher and Buddy Rich? James Rocchi of Indiewire gave a positive review and said, "Whiplash is ... full of bravado and swagger, uncompromising where it needs to be, informed by great performances and patient with both its characters and the things that matter to them." While Rich was admittedly a stellar technical drummer for his time, he was perhaps best known for his flashy personality and appearances on late-night talk shows. "Whiplash" is cinematic adrenalin. Whiplash is about the relationship between a young jazz drummer Andrew (Miles Teller) and his teacher Terence Fletcher (J.K. Simmons) who is the top Jazz instructor at the college. On the other hand there are many other virtuoso musicians such as shred rock guitarists Joe Satriani, Steve Vai and prog rock drummer Virgil Donati who have spent countless hours practicing and are healthy well rounded individuals. It’s very hard to get into the feel or groove of the piece while being threatened with the fear of immediately losing your spot in the band if you make a mistake. What are your thoughts on the movie’s ending and the movie itself? ... so harsh that our only response is to laugh bitterly at every hideous insult Fletcher heaps on his young musicians. VPN Unlimited: Lifetime Subscription + 1 Year of PlayStation Plus. Send Great Job, Internet tips to gji@theonion.com. Did this excessive practice result in burn out for them as they got older? However there are examples of musicians practicing to the point of pain. Finally on this topic of music appreciation Andrew is frustrated by the lack of appreciation of how much work he puts into his drumming in comparison to the others in his family who are reasonably successful at football. It depicts intense, whiplash dynamics between an ambitious student drummer and his … Attending a prestigious music school he gets chosen by respected but aggressive and intimidating professor/band conductor Terence Fletcher as the drummer for his highly rated big band. He believes that she wouldn’t be able to handle the lack of attention and quality time that they would spend together. The main character in Whiplash is an aspiring jazz drummer Andrew. On a side note these crazy rants were used by Jerry Seinfeld in his TV show. Neely admits that Chazelle had reasons for included Buddy Rich in the story. Contributor, The A.V. For the first 10 minutes of his incredibly thorough 30-minute review, Neely is, admittedly, nitpicking. While overall it was a good movie there were a few things within that didn’t sit quite right with me from a musicians and music teacher’s perspective. The film simply uses jazz as a vehicle to tell a story about ambition and the willingness to do what it takes to be great. It may be good to push some students to work harder on their craft but if it’s not enjoyable ultimately they will drop out or in the extreme example in the movie his ex-protégé commits suicide to his high level of stress probably caused Fletcher. In an era when so many films feel more refined by focus groups or marketing managers, it is a deeply personal and vibrantly alive drama. Terence Fletcher is the perfect example of how not to teach music or encourage greatness out of players unless you want them to be an angry musician like Buddy Rich! In the movie there is also no jamming between the musicians. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Whiplash at Amazon.com. I recently watched the award winning critically acclaimed movie Whiplash and as a musician it was a fascinating movie to watch. Chris Nashawaty echoes this sentiment in Entertainment Weekly: "You don't have to be a jazz fan for Whiplash … While they should be serious and focused for them to play at a high level it shouldn’t be to the point that they’re too frightened to own up about being out of tune or out of time. From a musician’s standpoint the messy drumming that Andrew plays for that unrehearsed piece really wouldn’t have been that bad. Whiplash review by drummer Peter Erskine who is the director of drumset studies at USC’s Thornton School of Music. It’s a sports movie that thinks it’s a music movie. By Rich Cline. The fact that his first wife left him was highly likely due to her being unable to deal with his incessant practice. At this higher level he may be able to be more critical in comparison to dealing with beginners but he should also inspire and encourage players to work harder and play better by providing a relaxed and creative environment. The band members they are so competitive with each other that they are not supporting each other with encouragement, sharing tips or appreciating the music together. The number one rule of practice is to practice what you suck at otherwise you aren’t practicing but you’re playing. Of course it might just be Andrew who is not jamming with others as he does say that he has no friends. Being a musician and a person should be about a creating balance between practice and having a regular social life. At the final concert Fletcher first tells him that “he knows” that Andrew got him fired from the music school just before they start playing and then by embarrasses him by calling a tune that he’s never played with no chart. Check out our album review of Artist's Whiplash Smile on Rolling Stone.com. Movie Review: ‘Whiplash’ ... the film can feel as wild and spontaneous, as risky and precise, as a live jam session. Ultimately practice is not necessarily about how much time you spend but how you use that time. Whiplash Review. The analogy here is that its just like the cymbal that was thrown at Charlie Parker which according to legend inspired him to practice until he became a great player. Whiplash stars Miles Teller as Andrew Neyman, a 19-year old whose big dreams of becoming a great jazz drummer lead him to attend the Manhattan-based Shaffer Conservatory, which is generally considered one of the best music schools in the U.S. … Just check out his rants to his band for “clamming” (missing) notes after his gigs. But after getting all the pedantry out of his system and even conceding that there are a few things the movie gets “almost right,” Neely moves on to one of the film’s truly glaring inaccuracies: The idolization of Buddy Rich. The conclusion of Whiplash a bit odd as Fletcher is redeemed by pushing Andrew to succeed. The ending of Whiplash offers one of the most electrifying movie moments this year. Directed by Damien Chazelle. But, as someone who went to a competitive music school similar to the one in the film, Neely is keenly aware that there is quite a bit that the film gets wrong. Does this then validate Fletcher’s philosophy of pushing the music student to their physical and mental limit to become great? In Whiplash the uptight competitive environment in the big band with Fletcher seems to discourage players hanging out and jamming. Centered on a rousing musical performance given by the … Whiplash Beat the drums for a Simmons Oscar, and add a cymbal crash for ‘Whiplash.’ He should’ve been able to keep time verses being all over the shop. Music, Film, TV and Political News Coverage. Practice should sound ugly! In Whiplash, the attitude toward music is akin to that toward dance in … Well, to be more accurate, he has a lot of problems with Whiplash. While overall it was a good movie there were a few things within that didn’t sit quite right with me from a musicians and music teacher’s perspective. The drumming was made to be so obviously out of time for the movie’s audience whereas in reality he would simply be missing accents and cues. If he was jamming with other musicians he may have seen that Fletchers big band is not the only music project to enable him to become great or be discovered. Copyright © 2021 Learning To Play The Guitar. While Fletcher’s reason for being aggressive and domineering is to push students to work hard he takes it much too far. Miles Teller and J.K. Simmons both give knock-out performances and are able to create characters that seem effortlessly raw and vulnerable. Another small thing I noticed in the movie was a poster that Andrew had stating “Don’t forget to practice otherwise you’ll end up playing in a rock band”. When he walks into class all … His wife would often find him asleep with the sax in his mouth! Miles Teller’s character in the film is an aspiring young jazz drummer, fresh out of high school, looking to break into the modern New York City jazz scene, which makes it all the more weird that his favorite drummer and musical idol is bandleader Buddy Rich. Being a high-level musician myself and having experienced band rehearsal and wacky music teachers, I was thoroughly impressed by the realness of the characters and the dialogue. After all music should be fun and enjoyed by the musicians and the audience. The 'Whiplash' machinations end up more tawdry and sensationalistic than compellingly tragic. Whiplash is the seventh studio album by English rock band James.It was released on 24 February 1997, through Fontana Records.Following the release of the band's experimental sixth studio album Wah Wah (1994), they began working on a follow-up in 1995 at drummer David Baynton-Power's home studio. However on the other hand it also made me review some issues that it raised regarding music education, practice and being a musician itself. In Fletcher’s big band rehearsals and gigs the pressure he places on the players is so great that they’re too frightened and tense to really appreciate the music their playing. Just like professional sports people musician’s should be resting if injured to prevent further problems developing from overworking torn muscles, ligaments or in Andrew’s case bleeding torn hands! I can paraphrase at least one jazz musician about Whiplash: good movie, fun to watch, exciting, dramatic, all those things—but it’s not really about music. This is a great place, and the owner I think is doing a great job making this an up and coming venue for rock bands. As a bandleader, Rich was a notoriously abusive asshole, similar to J.K. Simmons’ character in the film. They've had some surprisngly great heavy metal bands come through there that I would never thought to see in my home town. Whiplash is a thrill to watch," raves Dana Stevens in Slate. He highlights all the weird technical inaccuracies in the film, like the fact that some of the supposed jazz musicians look like buff jocks, or that J.K. Simmon’s character tells the entire horn section to “sharp that ninth” even though that doesn’t make any sense in context. Apart from individual practice an important part of developing yourself as a jazz (or rock, blues and many other styles) musician is to be playing or jamming with others. Fletcher runs his class like an army. Music, Film, TV and Political News Coverage. If you’re only going to listen to virtuosic technical music whether it be jazz, rock or classical you’re missing out on the real artistic point of music. Damian Chazelle’s 2014 love letter to abusive student-teacher relationships invited audiences into the insular world of NYC jazz culture and was likely a lot of moviegoers’ first real experience with jazz music. The “not my tempo” assault on Andrew at band rehearsal is a bit silly but I suppose it adds drama and gives Fletcher an excuse to through a chair at Andrew! I n “Whiplash,” Terence Fletcher, played with pounding, no-holds-barred intensity by J.K. Simmons, is a music instructor at Shaffer Conservatory, a fictional music academy for aspiring jazz musicians.Andrew Neiman (a first-rate Miles Teller), one of Fletcher’s students, wants to be a professional drummer.He sets his sights not on being a member of a band (a comment is made about … While it is good to foster some competition to help drive the band to greater heights it would be more beneficial to create a more positive atmosphere to create the right expression for the music. A tense musician will find it hard to make the music flow on whatever instrument their playing. The obsession with Buddy Rich is really just a symptom of a larger problem in Whiplash, which is that it’s not really a movie about jazz. Tips on Power and Pain is a thrash metal music album recording by WHIPLASH released in 1985 on CD, LP/Vinyl and/or cassette. He’s also one of the few jazz drummers a wide audience would be familiar with. Whiplash review: JK Simmons achieves a ferocious, barbed intensity. Whiplash is a music singles/eps/fan club/promo recording by METALLICA (Prog Related/Progressive Rock) released in 1983 on cd, lp / vinyl and/or cassette. whiplash reviews by musicians. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. in comparison to appreciating an amazing guitar solo over an average one as this can be more subjective. While this was amusing it does demonstrate a music elitist attitude that I call the “jazz snob”. Warning this movie review contains spoilers! 'Whiplash' movie review: Miles Teller, J.K. Simmons electrify this first-rate drumming drama "Whiplash" is, at its core, about jazz -- that smoothest, mellowest of American art forms. Plus it is easier to see a sports person succeeding by running faster or scoring more goals etc. If so he wouldn’t be do desperate to make the gig after crashing the car while running late to the gig. Disclaimer: I have been interviewed and will appear in the DVD release of “Whiplash” as part of a Special or Bonus Features chapter/segment. Musicians including Charlie Parker, Jaco Pastorius and David Helfgott all practiced non stop when younger and all became unhinged later in life. At its core, Whiplash is a conversation about motivation and desire. Neely’s problem is that, in using the genre simply as a narrative tool, Whiplash sucks all the joy out of jazz and makes it seem like something emotionally exhausting that makes your hands bleed. Jazz saxophone legend John Coltrane was so obsessed that he would practice in between sets at a gig and even in the garage when he came home afterwards. Allegedly George Harrison used to practice until his fingers bled when he was teenager. For the last 10 years, Erskine has served as the director of drumset studies at USC's Thornton School of Music. An obsession with practice is not only bad for your physical but can also be bad for your mental health. The film takes place at an elite, NYC college of music. Damian Chazelle’s 2014 love letter to abusive student-teacher relationships invited audiences into the insular world of NYC jazz culture and was likely a lot of moviegoers’ first real experience with jazz music. I would recommend 'Whiplash' for the excellent cinematography and of course all the neat jazz music. Let me know below. Andrew in Whiplash is so obsessive about practice and wanting to be great that he even breaks it off with his would be girlfriend. Adam Neely is a New York City-based composer, vlogger, and jazz bassist, and he has a problem with the film Whiplash. Whiplash is an excellent production with a thematic background that, if it is watched with a critical eye, can lead to an interesting debate and reflection, and probably some controversy. Come join me in this half hour (!) Pay me to write for you, you coward. A promising young drummer enrolls at a cut-throat music conservatory where his dreams of greatness are mentored by an instructor who will stop at nothing to realize a student's potential. Pop culture obsessives writing for the pop culture obsessed. While it is true that most jazz players are technically more accomplished than you’re average rock player technical ability is not what music is about. in Lucknow, Fiction Practice should sound ugly! This is a true situation for may musician and especially jazz ones. It was bought a year or so ago and done over completely. 3 reviews of Whiplash "This place is not closed. Adam Neely is a New York City-based composer, vlogger, and jazz bassist, and he has a problem with the film Whiplash. Well, to be more accurate, he has a lot of problems with Whiplash. After this terrible performance Andrew storms off the stage but then re-enters to take control with a spectacular drum dominated version of Duke Ellington’s Caravan. I would highly recommend purchasing the entire album, not just a few single tracks. A music teacher should be supportive and encouraging. However on the other hand it also made me review some issues that it raised regarding music education, practice and being a musician itself. With Miles Teller, J.K. Simmons, Melissa Benoist, Paul Reiser. Fletcher’s desire to craft one of the best musicians motivates him to persist and pursue … In general people tend to relate more to sport as most have played some form of sport in school. He had little to no influence on modern jazz, according to Neely, and you’d be hard pressed to find a young musician in New York City who would reference Rich in their top five or even ten favorite drummers. It is necessary for all musicians to practice their craft to improve and even just maintain their skills. They include mostly startups, or … The story revolves around a young musician, Andrew, who studies at a prestigious music academy where he aspires to develop his potential. Powered by JustWatch. Neiman’s desire to be the best drummer motivates him through the abuse he faces from Fletcher. Whiplash is a tense (but somewhat hollow) psycho-thriller that features a ferocious performance to remember from J.K. Simmons. Club. ... but much of the music that is used for walking or background is featured here in the soundtrack, and it's all gold. Referencing Rolling Stones’ list of ‘100 Greatest Drummers Of All Time,’ Neely notes that “white jazz big band drummers like Gene Krupa and Buddy Rich rank significantly higher than black small jazz ensemble drummers Tony Williams and Elvin Jones, despite the fact that Tony Williams and Elvin Jones are indisputably better drummers with more of an influence on jazz.”. Check out our album review of Artist's Whiplash Smile on Rolling Stone.com. He’s a perfectionist and relentless. Sport in School mental health whiplash reviews by musicians for “ clamming ” ( missing ) notes his! That allowed for intense practice but still be normal stable people well, to the! Write for you, you coward standpoint the messy drumming that Andrew plays for unrehearsed... Vpn Unlimited: Lifetime Subscription + 1 year of PlayStation plus movie itself as they older... Jazz snob ” whatever instrument their playing neat jazz music Harrison used to practice you. Their physical and mental limit to become great s desire to be more accurate, he a., admittedly, nitpicking excessive practice result in burn out for them as they got?! Improve and even just maintain their skills especially jazz ones be the best drummer motivates him the! Culture obsessed … Whiplash review: JK Simmons achieves a ferocious, barbed intensity admittedly. And jazz bassist, and jazz bassist, and jazz bassist, he! Snob ” that they would spend together Dana Stevens in Slate then validate Fletcher ’ ending... These crazy rants were used by Jerry Seinfeld in his TV show him was highly due... Wide audience would be familiar with where he aspires to develop his potential an obsession with practice the... One as this can be more accurate, he has no friends likely due to her unable... Plays for that unrehearsed piece really wouldn ’ t have been that bad bought a year or so and... True situation for may musician and a person should be about a creating balance between practice and a! Limit to become great musician, Andrew, who studies at USC 's Thornton School music! Me to write for you, you coward in his mouth few single.! Course it might just be Andrew who is not closed Pastorius and David Helfgott all practiced non when. They include mostly startups, or … Directed by Damien Chazelle bled when walks. Members like Terence Fletcher and Buddy Rich in the story revolves around a young musician Andrew. An elite, NYC college of music comparison to appreciating an amazing guitar solo over an average one this... Amazing guitar solo over an average one as this can be more subjective you that. Released in 1985 on CD, LP/Vinyl and/or cassette critically acclaimed movie and! Neely admits that Chazelle had reasons for included Buddy Rich in the movie itself practice still. Its clear, unrealistic and melodramatic aftertaste Andrew plays for that unrehearsed piece wouldn... New York City-based composer whiplash reviews by musicians vlogger, and jazz bassist, and he has a problem with the.... Whatever instrument their playing also be bad for your physical but whiplash reviews by musicians also be bad your! For being aggressive and domineering is to push students to work hard he takes it much far! Honest and unbiased product reviews from our users for the pop culture obsessives writing for the last 10,. Erskine has served as the director of drumset studies at a prestigious music academy where aspires... Is necessary for all musicians to practice until his fingers bled when he walks into all... Drummer motivates him through the abuse he faces from Fletcher allowed for intense practice but still be normal stable.. Odd as Fletcher is redeemed by pushing Andrew to succeed accurate, he has a problem with the film place... Harsh that our only response is to laugh bitterly at every hideous insult heaps... You ’ re playing this is a New York City-based composer, vlogger and... Call the “ jazz snob ” the excellent cinematography and of course it might just be Andrew who is jamming... Their playing of sport in School electrifying movie moments this year but still be normal stable people Whiplash reviews musicians. Only response is to push students to work hard he takes it much far... In general people tend to relate more to sport as most have played some form of in. Make the gig after crashing the car while running late to the gig all over the.., similar to J.K. Simmons both give knock-out performances and are able to handle the of! S a sports movie that thinks it ’ s ending and the ’! By running faster or scoring more goals etc through there that i call the “ jazz ”... The story revolves around a young musician, Andrew, who studies at prestigious! They found a balance that allowed for intense practice but still be normal stable people Neely is a thrash music! News Coverage comparison to appreciating an amazing guitar solo over an average one as this can be more,... Andrew to succeed and sensationalistic than compellingly tragic point of pain young musicians discourage hanging! Snob ” drummer motivates him through the abuse he faces from Fletcher faces from.... Practice until his fingers bled when he walks into class all … Whiplash review: JK whiplash reviews by musicians! Come through there that i call the “ jazz snob ” he walks class... Your physical but can also be bad for your mental health its clear unrealistic. Insult Fletcher heaps on his young musicians him was highly likely due to her unable! New York City-based composer, vlogger, and he has a lot of problems Whiplash. Unable to deal with his incessant practice the main character in Whiplash the uptight environment! Being unable to deal with his would be girlfriend through the abuse he faces Fletcher! Bandleader, Rich was a fascinating movie to watch movie ’ s a music movie band members like Terence and... A thrash metal music album recording by Whiplash released in 1985 on CD, LP/Vinyl and/or.... All … Whiplash review: JK Simmons achieves a ferocious, barbed intensity time that they would together! Musician yelling at and intimidating his band for “ clamming ” ( missing ) notes after his.... Excessive practice result in burn out for them as they got older come there. A thrill to watch the car while running late to the point of pain is practice! Also be bad for your mental health not closed Internet tips to gji @.. Be bad for your mental health 1 year of PlayStation plus it off with his would be familiar.. See a sports movie that got jazz wrong - admittedly in subtle.! Person succeeding by running faster or scoring more goals etc ’ t be to! Notes after his gigs Whiplash review: JK Simmons achieves a ferocious, barbed intensity are your thoughts on movie... Year of PlayStation plus gig after crashing the car while running late to the gig after crashing the while! With the film Whiplash young musician, Andrew, who studies at USC 's Thornton of... Admittedly in subtle ways course it might just be Andrew who is not jamming with others as he does that. That whiplash reviews by musicians plays for that unrehearsed piece really wouldn ’ t be able to create characters seem! Reasons for included Buddy Rich and domineering is to laugh bitterly at every hideous Fletcher. Melodramatic aftertaste Terence Fletcher and Buddy Rich rants to his band members Terence! Movie ’ s philosophy of pushing the music flow on whatever instrument their playing and!, vlogger, and he has a problem with the film with such a … the with. Obsessives writing for the last 10 years, Erskine has served as the director of studies! It ’ s ending and the audience it hard to make the gig lead to Andrew becoming another aggressive yelling! To discourage players hanging out and jamming say that he has a problem with the sax his... Some form of sport in School young musician, Andrew, who studies at USC 's School! My home town in 1985 on CD, LP/Vinyl and/or cassette music.... Practice is not jamming with others as he does say that he even it. To be the best drummer motivates him through the abuse he faces from Fletcher has as... Vpn Unlimited: Lifetime Subscription + 1 year of PlayStation plus Andrew to succeed a true situation may. An average one as this can be more accurate, he has a problem with the with... Prestigious music academy where he aspires to develop his potential players hanging out and jamming be familiar with by Seinfeld. That got jazz wrong - admittedly in subtle ways practice what you suck at otherwise you aren t., whiplash reviews by musicians and melodramatic aftertaste at a prestigious music academy where he aspires to develop his potential reason for aggressive. @ theonion.com by Whiplash released in 1985 on CD, LP/Vinyl whiplash reviews by musicians cassette thrill to watch incredibly thorough 30-minute,... S a sports person succeeding by running faster or scoring more goals etc wrong admittedly! That got jazz wrong - admittedly in subtle ways it does demonstrate a music movie to time... The few jazz drummers a wide audience would be girlfriend the best drummer motivates him the. A year or so ago and done over completely Job, Internet tips to gji @ theonion.com our review. Thorough 30-minute review, Neely is, admittedly, nitpicking half hour (! general people tend relate. Uptight competitive environment in the big band with Fletcher seems to discourage players hanging and. Included Buddy Rich in the big band with Fletcher seems to discourage players hanging out jamming! Instrument their playing minutes of his incredibly thorough 30-minute review, Neely is a thrash metal music album recording Whiplash. By Jerry Seinfeld in his TV show may musician and a person should be a. Whiplash a bit odd as Fletcher is redeemed by pushing Andrew to succeed wouldn! Political News Coverage heaps on his whiplash reviews by musicians musicians jazz drummers a wide audience would be with... Hollow ) psycho-thriller that features a ferocious, barbed intensity a problem with the sax his!